BigCommerce to Magento migration. Full Platform Comparison

Peter Markovich

Peter Markovich

Senior Front-End Developer, Magento 2 and UX/UI expertise

A complete comparison of BigCommerce and Magento Open Source for eCommerce

Are you thinking about switching from BigCommerce to Magento? No wonder! Magento offers a world of possibilities for growth and customization. 

While BigCommerce has been a reliable partner to many. But Magento opens up a realm of new opportunities. Our team has compiled a comparison of the two platforms to help you decide your store’s future.

Our team will help you find the best fit for your business

Reach out for a consultation and let’s embark on this journey together!

What is Magento Open Source?

Magento is an open-source e-commerce platform owned by Adobe. Since 2006, it has been getting more and more widely used. According to Built With, as of 2023, more than 140,000 websites worldwide are built using this platform. It’s a powerhouse for customization and scalability. Magento also offers a rich array of features that cater to the unique needs of your business.

Why migrate from BigCommerce to Magento? 

BigCommerce has been a great starting point for many merchants. It offers a user-friendly experience with enough features to get your business rolling. It’s reliable and functional but with some limits on what you can build.

Magento is powerful, flexible, and customizable. Think custom designs and development, extensive integrations, and a global reach. It’s perfect for businesses ready to step up their game.

Magento Open Source is a platform that can adapt to your changing needs as you grow. As your business grows, Magento can handle more traffic and products without breaking a sweat.

Who should consider migrating?

When to switch to Magento 

Here are some signs that you might find Magento benefits helpful for your business growth:

Hitting the ceiling with BigCommerce

Scaling up your business

Platform comparison: BigCommerce vs. Magento 

The choice between BigCommerce and Magento largely depends on your business needs, technical capabilities, and growth plans. BigCommerce is great for businesses seeking simplicity and ease of use. Magento is ideal for those needing advanced customization and scalability.

Ease of use

The choice between BigCommerce and Magento can be seen as a trade-off between ease of use and functionality.

For non-technical users, BigCommerce is the go-to. Its user-friendly nature makes it accessible to those without technical expertise. It’s perfect for small businesses or startups looking to establish an online presence quickly and with minimal fuss.

For technical users or those with resources, Magento shines with its extensive customization capabilities and advanced features. It’s ideal for businesses with specific needs, those planning to scale, or those who have the technical know-how or resources to harness its full potential.

BigCommerce: User-friendly and straightforward

Magento: Complex but powerful

Magento, on the other hand, is packed with tools for those who know how to use them. It boasts advanced features without BigCommerce counterparts:

Customization and flexibility

​​BigCommerce: Templated customization

Magento: The customization powerhouse

In contrast, Magento is like a blank canvas with a full spectrum of colors available for painting:

Ready to explore the possibilities with Magento?

Click below to review our Magento migration services
Learn more


When comparing BigCommerce vs. Magento 2, it’s clear that these platforms cater to different scales and complexities of business growth.

BigCommerce: Scaling with limitations

BigCommerce, akin to a reliable compact car, is great for navigating the city streets. But it might struggle on more demanding terrains.

Magento: Built for growth

When comparing BigCommerce vs. Magento, the latter is like a powerful off-road vehicle. It’s built to tackle challenging terrains and adapt to various environments.


BigCommerce offers a straightforward pricing model with different tiers based on the level of features you need. It includes hosting in its pricing. So, it can be a cost-effective solution for small businesses.

Magento requires a more significant initial investment, especially for Adobe Commerce (the paid version). It is free to use, but you need to consider the costs of hosting, development, and maintenance.

SEO and marketing

BigCommerce comes with built-in SEO features and marketing tools that are easy to use for beginners. At the same time, Magento offers more features for driving online traffic and sales:

BigCommerce vs. Magento 2 comparison summary

BigCommerceMagento 2
Ease of useUser-friendly, great for beginnersComplex, suited for those with technical knowledge
CustomizationGood, with some limitationsExcellent, highly customizable
Scalability Suitable for small to medium-sized businessesIdeal for large businesses and growth
Pricing Tiered pricing, includes hostingRequires more investment; free open-source version available
SEO and marketingBuilt-in, beginner-friendly Advanced features for aggressive strategies
Community and supportSupportive community, 24/7 supportLarge community, extensive resources for Magento Commerce

Opt for professional migration services

The migration from BigCommerce to Magento is a significant move, one that opens up a world of possibilities. However, this journey is intricate. This is where professional expertise and support become invaluable, ensuring a smooth and successful transition.

Migrating to Magento involves moving data, setting up new systems, and ensuring everything works as expected. It’s a complex process that requires technical know-how to avoid data loss, downtime, or other migration hiccups.

Alva Commerce, we tailor the Magento 2 migration process to align with your business goals. We understand that each business is unique, and so are its needs. With us, you can expect:

By opting for professional services at Alva Commerce, you ensure this critical transition is handled expertly and efficiently.

To wrap it up

When comparing BigCommerce vs. Magento 2 vs. Shopify, Magento Open Source stands out as a platform for tomorrow’s growth and success. It excels in customization and scalability and offers unparalleled features to empower your business.

Magento features robust functionality and adaptability. Thus, it enables you to create a store that truly reflects your brand’s personality and meets your specific business needs.

The decision to migrate from BigCommerce to Magento is a strategic move towards future-proofing your business. Magento opens doors to new opportunities. It enables you to connect with your customers in more meaningful ways. This is a platform that grows and evolves with your business.

At Alva Commerce, we understand the intricacies of both platforms. Our expertise in navigating the migration process from BigCommerce to Magento 2 ensures a seamless transition. So, you can harness the full potential of Magento’s capabilities. With our support, your journey from planning to launch and beyond becomes an exciting path.

Are you ready to set sail with your Magento store?

Reach out to us for a free consultation and let’s turn your vision into reality